05/20 Links Pt1: Fatah's Armed Militias Warn Israelis: "You Must Leave!"; Another Car Attack

From Ian:

Khaled Abu Toameh: Fatah's Armed Militias Warn Israelis: "You Must Leave!"
Many in the international community often refer to the Palestinian Fatah faction, which is headed by Palestinian Authority (PA) President Mahmoud Abbas, as a "moderate" group that believes in Israel's right to exist and the two-state solution.
What these people do not know is that Fatah, the largest faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), consists of several groups that hold different views than those expressed by Abbas and other English-speaking Fatah officials.
Some of these Fatah groups do not believe in Israel's right to exist and continue to talk about the "armed struggle" as the only way to "liberate Palestine and restore Palestinian national rights."
One of these groups is called The Aqsa Martyrs Brigade - El Amoudi Brigade.
The Aqsa Martyrs Brigades is Fatah's armed wing, established shortly after the beginning of the second intifada in September 2000. Although the Palestinian Authority leadership maintains that the group has been dissolved and its members recruited into its security forces, scores of gunmen continue to operate freely in Palestinian villages and refugee camps in the West Bank.
Based in the Gaza Strip, the El Amoudi Brigade, which consists of dozens of Fatah gunmen, is named after Nidal El Amoudi, a top Fatah operative killed by the Israel Defense Forces on January 13, 2008, after he carried out a series of armed attacks against Israeli civilians and soldiers during the second intifada.
During the last war in the Gaza Strip between Israel and Hamas ("Operation Protective Edge"), the El Amoudi Brigade claimed responsibility for firing dozens of rockets at Israeli cities and IDF soldiers.
US Reps. Grace Meng and Lee Zeldin: It’s Time to Give Israel the Means to take out Iranian Nukes
The negotiations over Iran’s nuclear program have engendered furious debate in Washington and in capitals across the world. But there are steps outside of the nuclear talks that President Obama can take to help ensure that the United States and its allies are stronger and more secure the day after a deal than they were the day before.
One such step would be to provide Israel with GBU-57 30,000-pound bunker-buster bombs (known as the Massive Ordnance Penetrators, or MOPs) and the means to carry them, in a quantity sufficient to destroy Iran’s most deeply buried nuclear sites.
At present, Israel possesses US-supplied 5,000-pound bunker-buster bombs. But experts doubt these bombs could seriously impede Iran’s nuclear development. On the other hand, there is little doubt that MOPs, which Israel lacks, are capable of destroying Iran’s nuclear sites.
As Michael Makovsky and Lt. Gen. David Deptula noted in a 2014 Wall Street Journal op-ed, the Defense Department has MOPs to spare, aircraft in storage that could carry the MOP payload and legal authority to transfer such arms to the Israelis.
Newsweek Mangles the Green Line
A story in Newsweek includes the following paragraph:
More than 350,000 Israelis live in West Bank settlements, with a further 200,000 in east Jerusalem. Under the Fourth Geneva Convention, the international community considers it illegal for Israel to encroach on Palestinian land by building settlements outside the Green Line, which was set out in 1949 to demarcate the Palestinian state following the 1948 Arab-Israeli war.
The 1949 so-called Green Line certainly did not set out to “demarcate the Palestinian state.” The Green Line refers to demarcation lines that separated Israeli and Arab forces at the conclusion of the 1948 War of Independence. These armistice lines were never intended to set permanent borders. In addition, the West Bank that Newsweek refers to was occupied by Jordan until 1967.
Following HonestReporting’s correspondence with Newsweek, the following correction has been added to the article:
Correction: This piece was updated on May 20 to clarify the definition of the Green Line as a demarcation line set out between Israeli and Arab forces following the 1948 Arab-Israeli War. The Green Line was not set out to demarcate a Palestinian state, as previously reported.



Palestinian Statehood - Separating Fact from Fantasy
The irony is that there never was a “peace process” except in the minds of the Western media and most Western leaders who have bought into all these lies and deceptions. The intention, rather, was to use international diplomatic pressure to force Israel into making strategic concessions that would ultimately lead to its destruction ….. as Arafat openly admitted in Johannesburg over twenty years ago.
Critics should note as well that the Palestinian educational system includes Palestinian poetry, schoolbooks, crossword puzzles and children’s music videos that teach Palestinian children that “Jews are the descendants of pigs and monkeys” and must be killed, and Palestinian leaders have openly declared that any future Palestinian state would be “Jew-free”. They are also using US and European foreign aid dollars to pay Palestinian terrorists in Israeli prisons as well as the families of Palestinian suicide bombers, and they continue to name marketplaces, town squares, tournaments, and cinemas after these suicide bombers whom they hail as “heroes” and “martyrs”. Nor is mention ever made of Hamas’s founding Charter that openly calls for the murder of Jews wherever they are, and for the destruction of their State.
The sad truth is that the Palestinians want a state not beside Israel, but in place of it. If critics would take the time to read what the Palestinians are saying to each other in Arabic (as translated by the Middle East Media Research Institute and Palestine Media Watch) as opposed to what they are saying to Western leaders and the Western media in English, they would understand the Islamic concept of taqqiyah (deception) and discover the real truth behind the Arab-Israeli conflict – not Israel’s refusal to accept a State of Palestine, but the Arab refusal to accept the existence of Israel as a Jewish state on what they consider to be Islamic lands.
Netanyahu’s new government needs to reject any such pressure to recognize a Palestinian state under current circumstances as should all Western leaders. To give up further lands in exchange for a deceitful peace is something that Israel tried in the 1990s with tragic results. It should not be repeated again.
Hotovely to Mogherini: The Palestinians, not Israel, walked out of negotiations
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is committed to a diplomatic process with the Palestinians, and it is the Palestinians who abandoned US-led negotiations a year and a half ago, Deputy Foreign Minister Tzipi Hotovely told the EU's foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini on Wednesday.
According to Hotovely’s office, the newly appointed deputy foreign minister told Mogherini that Israel's message to the Palestinians is that in order for a diplomatic process to take place they need to return to the negotiating table and not take unilateral steps against Israel in the international arena. .
Referring to the Jerusalem terror attack earlier in the day in which two Border Police officers were hurt by a Palestinian terrorists who tried to run them down, Hotovely said that Europe should strongly condemn terrorism, as well as back Israel’s demand for Palestinian recognition of Israel as the national home of the Jewish people.
Hotovely welcomed Mogherini's comment that she was interested in coming now after the establishment of the new Israeli government to listen to both sides, saying that her visit had a “great deal of importance.”
Hotovely to Norwegian FM: Press Palestinians to recognize Israel as Jewish state
Israel expects Norway to pressure the Palestinian leadership to recognize Israel as the Jewish national home, newly appointed Deputy Foreign Minister Tzipi Hotovely told visiting Norwegian Foreign Minister Borge Brende on Tuesday.
Hotovely, in her first high-level diplomatic meeting since her surprise appointment last Thursday, said it is very important for Israel that Europe and the Norwegian government do not support unilateral Palestinian steps in the international arena.
Hotovely, who has come out against a two-state solution, told Brende that a government was established in Israel which “represents a will for dialogue and is opposed to Palestinian unilateral moves.”
The deputy foreign minister told her guest Norway needs to understand that there is a consensus in Israel regarding preserving the unity of Jerusalem.
Not Pro-Peace? Judge Palestinians By the Same Standard as the Israelis
That’s a key point that Western Israel-bashers consistently forget. Israel has already offered the Palestinians statehood and almost all of the territory they demanded three times between 2000 and 2008 and refused to talk seriously to Livni last year in what amounts to a fourth “no” to peace. Were they to come to the talks prepared to recognize the legitimacy of a Jewish state no matter where its borders would be drawn they would find that no Israeli government would be able to resist taking them up on a two-state solution. But they can’t or won’t, a fact that renders the identity of the Israeli negotiators a piece of meaningless trivia.
But even if you want to be cynical about Shalom’s commitment to the process, it bears asking why the same people who think him insufficiently devoted to peace have no problem accepting and even praising Palestinians who do far worse. PA negotiator Saeb Erekat has regularly denounced Israel and engaged in libelous attacks on it while always denying it the right to be a Jewish state. His boss, PA leader Abbas, embraces and honors terrorists with Jewish blood on their hands, and has also incited Palestinians to attack Jews in order to compete with Hamas for popularity with a public that links bloodshed with political legitimacy. There has never been a Palestinian negotiating team that hasn’t stated positions that are far more extreme than anything Shalom ever said, yet never are they denounced as obstacles to peace.
Unlike with the Israelis, no one says Erekat’s belief in the “right of return” disqualifies him for the talks even though that marks him as a man that will never accept Israel’s existence. But Shalom’s skepticism is treated as proof that Israel won’t negotiate. Instead of worrying about the Israelis, who have already shown they’ll trade land for the hope of peace (and got terror instead), it’s time for the international community to start holding the Palestinians accountable. Until they do, they’ll never have an incentive to start talking in good faith.
Former Secretary of Defense Robert Gates Says Better Iran Deal Still Possible (VIDEO)
A “better deal” over Iran’s nuclear program that will not “scare [U.S.] allies half to death” has yet to be achieved, but is still possible, contended former Secretary of Defense Robert Gates in an interview with Face the Nation on Monday.
To achieve a good deal, sanctions must be phased out over time “based on performance,” which Gates said was always the U.S. position, and which Iran’s leaders reject in favor of immediate relief.
He said Iran was likely to cheat unless an “on-demand inspection at all facilities, including military facilities” is established.
The former defense secretary said he had “several concerns” over the current framework, which faces a June 30 deadline and needs congressional approval.
As talks resume, Iran vows no inspection of military sites
Iran’s supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei on Wednesday ruled out allowing nuclear inspectors to visit military sites or to question scientists, state media reported.
“We have already said that we will not allow any inspections of military sites by foreigners,” the official IRNA news agency quoted him as saying.
“They also say that we must allow interviews with nuclear scientists. This is interrogation. I will not allow foreigners to come and talk to scientists who have advanced the science to this level,” Khamenei said.
Other Iranian officials have repeatedly claimed that inspectors would not be given freedom of access to nuclear facilities — directly contradicting US officials who tout comprehensive inspections as being a key element of a final deal.
Iran willing to extend nuclear talks
If Iran and the world powers powers fail to hammer out a nuclear accord by a July 1 deadline, Tehran would be willing accept an extension of talks, an Iranian foreign ministry spokeswoman said Wednesday.
In a framework deal signed between the sides in early April, Iran agreed to curb some aspects of its contentious nuclear program in exchange for a lifting of economic sanctions.
Israel has warned that the deal in its current form is insufficient and may still enable Iran to to develop nuclear weapons. Iran insists its nuclear project will be used for peaceful purposes only.
“We have said that if the path of drafting the text and reaching a possible agreement requires prolonging the talks, we won’t have any problem and will be ready to do it,” Iranian foreign ministry spokeswoman Marziyeh Afkham said, according to Fars News.
Clifford D. May: The summit that wasn't
I'd venture to guess that most of what you heard about U.S. President Barack Obama's summit last week was ‎wrong. To start, it wasn't a "summit." That term, coined by Winston Churchill, implies a meeting ‎of heads of government. But the most important Arab leader invited by Obama, King ‎Salman of Saudi Arabia, stayed home, as did the rulers of the United Arab Emirates and Oman. ‎King Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa of Bahrain decided his time could be spent more productively at ‎the Royal Windsor Horse Show outside London.‎
You also may have heard that the reason the leaders of the Gulf Cooperation Council ‎didn't attend was that they were put off by the prospect of international travel. Trust me: Flying ‎in one's own customized jet is a lot less wearying than going coach.‎
It is true that by not showing up they were making a statement. But to say they "snubbed" the ‎president, as several commentators did, is imprecise. They were demonstrating not disdain but ‎distrust: They know Obama wants to convince them that the agreement he's bending over ‎backwards to conclude with the Islamic Republic of Iran will help stabilize a Middle East that ‎grows more chaotic by the day. They're not buying it. So they sent envoys empowered only to ‎say: "Thank you, Mr. President. I will convey your views to His Majesty."‎
Negotiations with Iran were intended to prevent the world's leading sponsor of terrorism from ‎acquiring a nuclear weapons capability. At this point, they are veering toward providing Iran's ‎rulers with two paths to that capability: a slow but sure one if they abide by the agreement's ‎stipulations; a faster one if they violate their obligations -- as they have in the past.‎
Elliott Abrams: 7 years in prison for 7 Baha'i leaders
This week marks a landmark in the Islamic Republic of Iran's crimes against that country's ‎small Baha'i community: Seven years ago this week, the regime imprisoned seven peaceful ‎Baha'i leaders. What is the true nature of Iran's clerical regime? The answer is visible in its ‎continuing brutal treatment of this religious minority, just 300,000 people in a nation of 70 ‎million -- less than 0.5% of the population.‎
From its early days, the Islamic republic has singled out the Baha'i for discrimination and ‎then persecution. They are seen as apostates from Islam, because their faith originated in ‎Iran in the 19th century. The existence of the Baha'i international headquarters and shrine ‎in Haifa, Israel have led to repeated accusations of spying and treason. Hundreds of Baha'i ‎were killed and thousands imprisoned in the early decades of theocratic rule after the ‎revolution in 1979. Baha'i institutions were all closed in 1983; Baha'i marriages are not ‎recognized; Baha'i's are discriminated against in employment; their holy places have been ‎destroyed; and Baha'i children are kept out of universities. The U.N.'s "special rapporteur on ‎the situation of human rights in the Islamic Republic of Iran," in his March 2015 report, ‎noted one emblematic and shameful incident: When roughly 1 million students took the ‎national math exam in 2014, a Baha'i student placed 113th in the entire country. But he was ‎nevertheless barred from attending a public university.‎
Expert: Turmoil and Repression in Kurdish Iran Exposes Regime’s Fears of Ethnic Separatism
The recently suppressed unrest in the Kudish region of Iran, “is an indication not of the regime’s strength, but of its potential weakness,” Jonathan Spyer, director of the Rubin Center, wrote in a column for The Jerusalem Post on Friday.
The suppression of any hint of Kurdish separatism has remained in place ever since. Education in Kurdish remains forbidden; any sign of attempts at political organization is ruthlessly suppressed by the Revolutionary Guards.
The hostility of the Iranian regime to the slightest hint of separatism derives not solely or mainly from ethnic tensions between Persians and Kurds. Even the most modest Kurdish demands for greater local autonomy raise the specter for the regime of ethnic separatism. Iran is a divided society ethnically, with only 49 percent of the population consisting of ethnic Persians; the rest are a mixture of Azeris, Baluchis, Kurds and Arabs.
Thus, the brutal and total repression of Kurdish demands is an indication not of the regime’s strength, but of its potential weakness. Tehran fears that were the demands of one minority ethnicity to be accommodated – even partially – this would risk opening the floodgates for other demands.
Washington Post Reporter’s Espionage Trial in Iran To Start Next Week
According to the report, Rezaian’s defense lawyer, Leila Ahsan, confirmed that Rezaian had “been charged with ‘espionage’ offences, but said it was unclear whether the trial would be open to the public.”
Rezaian is charged with, among other things, having ties with the National Iranian American Council (NIAC), an organization that supports stronger ties between the United States and Iran.
In a statement released today, Martin Baron, executive editor of The Washington Post, criticized the injustice of Iran’s judicial system, and revealed the paper’s efforts to send an editor to Iran to observe the trial.
MEMRI: Iranian Attempt To Break The Saudi Sea Blockade On Yemen Could Lead To Violent Confrontation
In MEMRI's assessment, neither Iran nor the Saudis are going to back down in this matter. Saudi Arabia will only allow the Iranian vessel through after it undergoes UN inspection, and Iran will not permit the Saudis to board it. Either a violent confrontation or a Saudi takeover of the ship is likely.
It should be noted that the Iranians would like the Saudis to instigate a violent confrontation, in which Iran would play the role of a provider of humanitarian aid that is being attacked.
This tense scenario could erupt into a localized conflict at sea that could escalate to a broader confrontation in the Arabian Peninsula and elsewhere in the Middle East.
Saudi Arabia has, in recent days, made diplomatic efforts. Alongside this Iranian provocation, it convened the May 18-19 Riyadh summit, an intra-Yemeni dialogue among all Yemeni political parties except the Houthis, passing resolutions backing the position of Saudi Arabia and the coalition for resolving the Yemen crisis on several levels – domestic, regional, and international – via the UN.
Under these circumstances, it can be assumed that the U.S. will intervene to try to find a diplomatic solution to the crisis; such a solution might be attainable, although in light of the stances of both sides, this cannot be certain. However, even if a last-minute diplomatic solution is found, this skirmish could exacerbate the ongoing conflict between Saudi Arabia and Iran and lead to a violent escalation at some point in the near future.
In this context, it should be mentioned that the five-day ceasefire that began on May 12 has not been renewed, and, according to Yemeni Foreign Minister Yassin, the ceasefire collapsed following violations by the Houthis – thus legitimizing the ongoing Saudi airstrikes against them.
Defying US, Iranian warships escort cargo vessel toward Yemen
Two Iranian warships have joined a cargo ship that Tehran says is carrying supplies to Yemen.
US Army Col. Steve Warren said the ships linked up overnight Monday, setting up a possible conflict as the US insists the supplies go to Djibouti, where the United Nations is coordinating humanitarian aid for Yemen.
A US official said there’s no evidence the Iranian ship is carrying lethal or military aid. The official spoke on condition of anonymity because the official was not authorized to discuss the matter publicly.
The vessel, the Iran Shahed, is carrying nearly 2,800 tons of aid including flour, rice, canned food, medical supplies and bottled water, all urgently needed in the conflict-wracked and impoverished state, according to Iran. It is expected to reach port on Thursday, and entered the Gulf of Aden on Sunday.
American, Foreign Activists on Iranian Flotilla to Yemen
There are some important things to know about the Iranian cargo shop Iran Shahed, which left Bandar Abbas, Iran on 11 May and expects to get to the Houthi-held port of Hodeidah, on the Red Sea, on 20-21 May. Iran claims the ships is carrying only humanitarian-aid cargo.
1. The ship itself is on the U.S. Treasury list of vessels and shipping entities under sanction due to complicity in arms proliferation.
2. We aren’t going to do anything about that.
3. The Saudis have imposed a blockade on Yemen and are determined to prevent the importation of arms (i.e., from Iran to the Houthis) by air or sea.
4. Iran is escorting Iran Shahed with naval ships, and has basically threatened to fight if the Saudis try to stop the ship.
5. There are two Americans riding Iran Shahed, along with activists from France and Germany, and members of the Iranian media – because in radical circles, the ship’s mission is now a cause célèbre like the occasional “flotilla” attempts to break the blockade of Gaza’s coast.
Potential Iran Deal Sends Terror Stocks Soaring (satire)
Leaks from Washington, Tehran, and Switzerland of an imminent nuclear deal roared through Wall Street today sending terror stocks soaring in afterhours trading. Reports indicate than any deal will include the release of over $100 billion in frozen Iranian funds. Noted hedge fund manager, Gree D. Bassard, seemed to speak for the mood. “$100 billion’s a lot of scratch. And what are the Iranians going to spend it on? Give you a hint – it won’t be booze or bacon.”
Of course this isn’t the first time that investors risked getting burned in the terror market. The sector slumped after President Obama announced his plan for the US to leave Iraq. Despite a brief spike, the sector failed to make much progress after ISIS burst onto the scene. Market analysts forecast that this time it will be different. “Iran has a lot of unfulfilled demand for these sorts of supplies,” Ms. Brea KN Rekrd said in a conference call. “This sector’s awash in undervalued assets. I’ve already made strong buy recommendations for e-Shrapnel.com and C4-4U. I’m telling you – this sector is going to explode.”
As if to prove this prediction, CNBC reported that Mad Money host Jim Cramer was killed today as he urged his viewers to “dive in” and buy Boomy Vest, a manufacturer of explosive clothing. Cramer was wearing one of the company’s top of the line, ‘Martyr Makers’ at the time of the explosion. Boomy Vest CEO, Herman Lipshitz, issued a statement. “My heart goes out to the Cramer family. I would note that our vest took out half of Jim’s crew and injured 20% of the live audience. And that was without the optional rat poison laced shrapnel! We make a quality product.”
Terrorist shot dead after running down 2 Border Police officers in east Jerusalem
According to Police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld, the attack took place shortly before 10 a.m. when the unidentified assailant rammed his car into a male and female officer, who sustained light-to moderate wounds to their legs and hips.
“The terrorist drove into them while they were on patrol in A-Tur and both were treated at the scene and then evacuated to Hadassah University Medical Center in Ein Kerem and Shaare Zedic Medical Center,” he said.
“A police officer at the scene shot the terrorist, leaving him in critical condition,” Rosenfeld continued. “He died shortly after from his injuries.”
Rosenfeld said multiple police units arrived to cordon off the area and initiated an investigation to determine if the suspect acted alone.
Hit-and-Terrorist Cousin of Mercaz HaRav Mass Murderer
The Jerusalem Arab terrorist who ran over two police officers and tried to kill them is the cousin of the driver who carried out the massacre of eight Mercaz HaRav Yeshiva students in Jerusalem in 2008, according to Arab media.
Wednesday’s hit-and-run terrorist was identified as Amran Omar abu Dahim, 42, from the Jabel Mukaber neighborhood located between the Talpiot and A-Tur neighborhoods in southeastern Jerusalem.
He is the cousin of Ala abu Dahim, who drove his vehicle in 2008 to the Mercaz HaRav yeshiva in Jerusalem, entered the building with a violin case and then pulled out a rifle and gunned down yeshiva students,.
The massacre shocked the world, even the bleeding-heart liberals since it occurred at a widely-known yeshiva that is located less than a mile from the Central Bus Station in Jerusalem.
More Than a Dozen Terror Suspects Arrested in West Bank Raids
Israeli soldiers detained more than a dozen suspected terrorists overnight Monday into Tuesday in raids across Judea and Samaria. A total of 17 suspects were arrested.
Seven of the detainees were members of the Hamas terrorist organization, according to IDF officials.
Two were taken into custody in the village of Fara’a, located northeast of Shechem (Nablus.) Two others were detained in a raid carried out southwest of Jenin, in Jaba’a.
Another member of the Gaza-based terror group was arrested in Beit Fajar, southwest of Bethlehem and quite close to the Gush Etzion junction. Three other suspects – including two alleged Hamas members – were arrested in nearby Hebron.
Israelis Mock New Hamas Propaganda Video Seeking to Scare IDF Recruits
Israelis mocked a new Hamas propaganda music video that appeared on the Facebook page of the Hamas-affiliated Shehab News Agency on Tuesday meant to scare the country’s citizens away from joining the Israeli Army and confronting the terror group.
The soundtrack in the clip, which is sung to the tune of “Be A Man” by popular Israeli singer Zohar Argov, quickly went viral in the Jewish state.
The video sought to demoralize Israelis and discourage them from joining the ranks of the IDF through highlighting the benefits that a non-military life has to offer, like clubbing and partying. It features an Israeli who wants to be a soldier, but instead enjoys various luxuries of the civilian high-life including a flashy car and a house in Savyon, one of Israel’s most affluent neighborhoods.
The video has attracted almost 120,000 views so far, many of them from Israeli web surfers who took a humorous and nonchalant approach to what they termed a “great Zohar Argov cover song.”
“Hamas puts out the anthem of the summer,” said one. Another commented that Hamas was “continuing the grand tradition” of soldiers making complaint songs about their army service, “so they deserve some applause.”
New York Times Report Reveals Libya New Leader ‘Sought Discreet Relationship With Israel’
The exposé of personal correspondences between Hillary Clinton and a longtime friend and adviser reported by the New York Times on Monday indicated, among other things, an inchoate back channel facilitating new ties between post-Gaddafi Libya and Israel.
The emails between Clinton and Sidney Blumenthal about the inner-workings of Libya following the death of the North African country’s dogged dictator, Muammar Gaddafi, included one correspondence that suggested new Libyan leader, Mohamed Magariaf, would “seek a discrete relationship with Israel.”
Clinton, encouraged by the news, forwarded the message to her deputy Jake Sullivan — a current adviser to the Obama administration for negotiations over Iran’s nuclear program — saying he “should consider passing to Israelis,” according to the Times report that was released on Monday.
Libya and Israel had no diplomatic ties under Gaddafi, and neither do any exist today. From 2011 to 2012, when these Clinton-Blumenthal intelligence-style correspondences were written there were no open relations between Libya’s de facto National Transitional Council government, either.
But in 2011, politically active French philosopher Bernard-Henri Lévy generated a brief scandal when he apparently outed the NTC’s plan to forge better ties with the Jewish state.
Smuggled ISIS Rings Seized at Tel Aviv Airport: Israel Officials

The "delivery of 120 rings bearing an insignia associated with Daesh terrorist organization" was intercepted at Ben Gurion Airport, Israel's main international hub, according to a statement released by the Israel Tax Authority. Daesh is the the group's acronym in Arabic.
Israeli officials told NBC News that the seizure had taken place around two-and-a-half weeks ago but they would not give a specific date. News of the rings only came out on Tuesday.
The jewelry, which had been imported from Turkey, was classified as "prohibited propaganda" and destroyed, the authority added.
Israel denies talks with Hamas on seaport, prisoner swap
An Israeli official denied a Jordanian report Tuesday that Israel was negotiating directly with Hamas over the establishment of a floating seaport between Turkish-controlled northern Cyprus and the Gaza Strip.
Quoting unnamed “Western diplomatic sources,” ad-Dustour daily claimed that Israeli and Hamas negotiators have been meeting both in Israel and in various European capitals to discuss the establishment of the commercial port, a long-sought demand by Palestinians in Gaza.
According to the report, they also discussed the exchange of a body of an Israeli-Ethiopian man who had entered Gaza in recent months for a number of Hamas prisoners serving time in Israeli jails.
Speaking to The Times of Israel on condition of anonymity, an Israeli official denied “any negotiations with Hamas.”
Has the Pentagon Found a Solution to 'Terror Tunnels'?
Detecting such tunnels is currently extremely difficult, but the US military may have developed a solution.
According to Channel Two, at a recent Department of Defense exhibition held by the Pentagon developers showcased a new system which can detect tunnels up to eight meters underground, and even track tunneling progress in realtime.
The system uses both soundwaves and vibration receptors to track underground tunnels, and has reportedly already proven itself after being deployed along the US border with Mexico, where drug-smuggling tunnels are a major problem.
Each time a tunneler drills or strikes the ground the sensors pick up the vibrations and are able to track them back to their source, providing operators with an accurate location.
The technology could also provide a solution to growing concerns along Israel's northern border with Lebanon over possible attack tunnels dug into Israel by Hezbollah.
The next Gaza war that nobody wants
Israel and Hamas would probably rather not go to war again this summer, but rogue Hamas factions may push the two into conflict again.
Hamas’s Gaza-based political leaders, who have failed to attract funding to rebuild homes and other key civilian needs after Israel laid waste to much of their military infrastructure, understand that another war would be devastating. Likewise, Israel would rather keep its powder dry for more serious threats, including Hezbollah to its north, Islamic State in Syria, and possibly even Iran.
Of the two, Hamas’s political leadership is probably more wary. The regime in Egypt, which sees Hamas as an extension of the Muslim Brotherhood movement it toppled in 2013, has destroyed an estimated 2,000 smuggling tunnels – and even flooded some with tear gas – thereby cutting off Hamas’s access to weapons, cash and goods. Hamas leaders know that if they are ever to convince Egypt to open its borders, they will need to charm Cairo’s financial patrons in Saudi Arabia, who are busy leading an air campaign in Yemen against the Iran backed Houthis in Yemen.
Hamas knows that another war with Israel, especially one fought with Iranian weapons, will not necessarily earn the favor of Saudi Arabia, Egypt and the other Sunni states. Between the Iranian nuclear threat, the expansion of the Islamic State and other regional threats, the Sunnis don’t want any more conflict in the region – even against Israel – if it can yield Iran any more leverage than it currently has.
Hamas Using Truce to Prepare for Next Clash With Israel
In the nine months since Hamas fought a 50-day war with Israel, the terrorist group has exploited the months of recent quiet to prepare itself for the next clash, which it assumes will inevitably come.
Hamas is in the midst of a full-scale rocket rearmament and tunnel reconstruction drive. The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) is also preparing its responses for the next time the Gazan regime attacks.
Despite its extremist ideology, Hamas does not appear interested in sparking another costly and damaging war now – and yet, a large number of potential triggers are in place that could start one anyway.
The Hamas military wing, the Izzadin Al-Qassam Brigades, has restarted its domestic rocket and mortar production program, and built, in all likelihood, more than 1,000 rockets since the August 26 ceasefire went into effect.
IMF Calls for Donor Support for PA Territories
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) called on Tuesday for more donor aid to support the economic recovery of the Palestinian Authority (PA)-assigned areas of Judea and Samaria and of Gaza, AFP reported.
The IMF said in a report that the reconstruction process in Gaza following last summer’s war between Israel and Hamas "is moving far more slowly than expected."
The economic cost of the 50-day war is estimated at $4 billion for Gaza, the IMF noted.
"While notable progress has been made recently with the provision of materials for the repair of individual homes, larger construction projects that are required for a job-creating economic recovery are still pending," the report said.
According to the IMF, of the $3.5 billion promised for the reconstruction of Gaza at the Cairo Conference in October, only about 27 percent had been disbursed by mid-April.
Egypt: Police Accused of Sexual Assault on 'Massive Scale'
Egyptian authorities are using sexual assault on a 'massive' scale against detainees, NGO the International Federation for Human Rights said Tuesday.
The report suggested that men, women, and children are being abused systemically to "eliminate public protest," according to the BBC.
Charges state that police, intelligence officers, and the military are subjecting prisoners to "virginity tests" and rape as they await trial. Students, human rights activists, homosexuals, and children are the most common victims, it said.
Egypt has refused to respond to the allegations until it sees a copy of the report.
Kurdish musician in Turkey sentenced to 10 years in prison for singing in Kurdish
If you are planning to visit Turkey soon, keep in mind that singing a Kurdish song, choosing a Kurdish name for your child, or just saying a few Kurdish words is still unacceptable and might even constitute a crime.
Nudem Durak, 24, a musician who sings and teaches Kurdish folk songs at the Mem û Zîn Culture and Art Center in the Kurdish town of Cizre has recently been arrested and sentenced to 10.5 years in prison for “being a member of a terrorist organization.”
“All kinds of activities that Kurds engage in – cultural, linguistic or even personal ones – are used as evidence against them in their court files,” Rojhat Dilsiz, Durak’s lawyer said. “Even the telephone conversations that Durak had with fellow artists were used as evidence against her.”
Durak was first arrested in 2009 and spent about eight months in jail until her first trial, as a result of which she was released pending trial. But after the Supreme Court approved of her punishment, she was arrested again.
Teen Girl Shot in the Head for Appearing in Turkish Version of The Voice
A teenage Turkish woman competing in a televised singing contest similar to The Voice is in critical condition after being shot in the head Monday.
The Daily Mail reports Mutlu Kaya, 19, previously received death threats for her decision to join Turkey’s Sesi Çok Güzel competition on the country’s private channel Fox.
According to the site, the young woman once told producers, “When they heard that I was going to join the competition, they told me they would kill me. I am afraid.”
Her fears were validated Monday as she rehearsed inside her home in the Ergani district of Diyarbakir province, when an attacker broke into her backyard and shot her through a back window from the residence’s garden, striking her in the head.
The state Anatolia news agency said Tuesday a suspect in the shooting had not been named, but the New York Daily News reports one of four people who have been arrested in connection with the attack is the woman’s former-boyfriend.
The country’s Posta newspaper reported prior to the attack that Kaya had been threatened by someone within her own family for going to Istanbul to take part in the show.

Egyptian attackers again explode gas pipeline to Israel, Jordan

From JPost and BBC:

Saboteurs on Wednesday blew up a pipeline running through Egypt's North Sinai near the town of El-Arish that supplies gas to Israel and Jordan, a security source told Reuters.

"An unknown armed gang attacked the gas pipeline," the security source said, adding that the flow of gas to Israel and Jordan had been hit.

"Authorities closed the main source of gas supplying the pipeline and are working to extinguish the fire," the source said, adding there was a tower of flame at the scene.
--
Neighbouring Jordan depends on Egyptian gas to generate 80% of its electricity while Israel gets 40% of its natural gas from the country. Syria also imports gas from Egypt.
Israel's Tamar and Leviathan gas fields can't go online fast enough.

AFP downplays Muslim Brotherhood statement on Bin Laden

From AFP:
Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood said on Monday that Osama bin Laden, who was killed by US forces in Pakistan, did not represent Islam and said the United States should pull out of Iraq and Afghanistan.

"Islam is not Bin Laden," Mahmud Ezzat, the Brotherhood's number two, told AFP.

"After September 11, there had been a lot of confusion. Terrorism was mixed up with Islam," he said. "In the coming phase, everyone will be looking to the West for just behaviour."
Indeed, the Muslim Brotherhood said this. But AFP left out what else they said.

From the Ikhwanweb website, in Arabic:
While Islam denounces violence and terrorism it believes it was not necessary to resort to assassination stressing a fair trial of any criminal whatever the crime would have sufficed.

It is on this note that the MB calls on the Western world, its people and governments to not link Islam with terrorism, and to correct the erroneous image which has been created in this regard.

The MB however confirms its belief that there is a difference between combat and resistance stressing that combating violence is necessary however each country has its right as stipulated in international conventions guaranteed by divine laws to defend itself against oppression against innocent people as is the case of the Palestinian people and Israel's Zionists.

Ending its statement the group cites that so long as occupation remains resistance is legitimate and it calls on the United States, NATO and the EU to end the occupation in Afghanistan and Iraq, and recognize the legitimate rights of the Palestinian people.

Furthermore the MB calls on the US to end its intelligence operations and to cease from interfering in the internal affairs of any Arab or Muslim country.
The Muslim Brotherhood statement, rather than denouncing Al Qaeda as AFP implies, actually condones Al Qaeda actions against allied troops in Afghanistan and Iraq, as well as Palestinian Arab terrorism.

Not quite as peaceful as some like to pretend.

(h/t Dan for last link)

If you needed any more proof that Israel boycotters act like toddlers

I find this article from Electronic Intifada to be unintentionally revealing.
A key figure in the creation of the International Criminal Court (ICC) is facing harsh criticism from Palestinians over planned lectures at Israeli universities this month in violation of the growing international boycott.

The noted Egyptian-American jurist Cherif Bassiouni is scheduled to speak on Thursday at Tel Aviv University on “The role of the ICC as justice mechanism: Does it enhance the prospects for Israeli-Palestinian peace?”

He is also scheduled to speak on 25 May at Hebrew University, which has also faced persistent criticism for its complicity in the Israeli occupation.

Bassiouni chaired the drafting committee that wrote the ICC’s founding statute in 1998.
And then:
In response to inquiries from The Electronic Intifada, PACBI, the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel, said it had been “shocked to learn” that Bassiouni would speak at Tel Aviv University “in defiance of the guidelines set by the BDS [boycott, divestment and sanctions] movement for the academic boycott of Israel.”...
"There is simply no excuse for academics who count themselves among those who care about human rights to defy this institutional boycott,” PACBI states.

“Respecting our boycott guidelines is the minimal form of solidarity that we are asking for. Is it too much to ask?”

In other words, we decided to make a bunch of rules for everyone in the world - and the rest of the world isn't playing by our rules! Waaaah!

A self-appointed group of haters really think that the stuff they dream up and insist everyone else does has the force of international law, and if anyone violates their "rules" then they must be punished.

It is like they think that  they live in a real life version of "Simon Says" and people must do what they say.When real people - even those who are not particularly pro-Israel - act like adults who can make their own decisions, the BDSers scream and whine and pout.

PA: Israeli Antibiotics Erasing Direct Palestinian Descent From Local Bacteria (PreOccupied Territory)

Our weekly column from the humor site PreOccupied Territory

Check out their Facebook page.



Ramallah, May 20 - Palestinian officials accused Israel today of using antibiotics to kill locally occurring bacteria whose genetic sequence proves that Palestinians are directly descended from the most ancient forms of life in the contested land.

Negotiator Saeb Erekat leveled the charges at a press conference Tuesday afternoon, taking up a theme he has revisited a number of times. Last year Erekat claimed Palestinians were descended from the Canaanites, apparently in an effort to forge a link to pre-Israelite civilizations, thereby establishing a claim that historically precedes the Jewish one, and he has previously invoked the Natufians, an even more ancient group that preceded even the Canaanites. The statement linking Palestinians to the first living organisms is likely a similar effort to outflank potential efforts to question the pedigree of the Palestinian claim.

"Israel is using Teva-manufactured pharmaceuticals to destroy the organisms carrying the DNA which proves Palestinian ancestry to the exclusion of the spurious Jewish claim," asserted Erekat, whose colleagues in the Jerusalem Waqf are overseeing excavation and renovation of the Temple Mount specifically to remove archaeological evidence of the Jewish temples that stood there. "We Palestinians are the proud descendant of the first microorganisms to ooze from the primordial reaches of prehistory in this land. No one has the right to dispute this."

For decades, Israelis have been using antibacterial agents to destroy such microorganisms, often millions at a time. "The massacre of our genetic cousins continues apace, and the cruelty of the Zionist oppressor usurpers knows no bounds. Even as we speak, countless bacterial brethren of the Palestinian people - brethren whose incontrovertible link to us is encoded in prokaryotic DNA - are slaughtered at the cruel hands of Israeli disinfectants, medications, antiseptics, detergents, gastric acids, and leukocytes," he said. "These killings take place with the nonchalance we have come to expect from the arrogant Zionists - on toilet seats, on human skin, in the bloodstream - everywhere. No location is sacred enough, or off limits, for the Zionists to exercise their micro-ethnic cleansing."

"Having failed to successfully prosecute genocide against us, the Zionists seek to eliminate the evidence that we were, in fact, here first," continued Erekat, whose Bedouin ancestors are documented as migrating to the land in the nineteenth century.

Other Palestinian officials echoed the charges, and promised to take action on the international stage. "We have already applied to UNESCO to have these local bacteria declared a World Heritage Organism," said Nabil Abu Rudeineh. "The impunity with which Israel acts in this regard must be stopped."

In contrast, leaders of the Hamas movement blasted Erekat. "The heresy inherent in his remarks is intolerable," said Darween Wasaful, a spokesman for the organization. "Everyone knows humanity was specially created by Allah from clay, and that the sun orbits the Earth."

Islamists in Jordan handing out sweets for OBL's "martyrdom"

Jordan's Ammon News reports that Jordan's Islamists are celebrating "the martyrdom of Sheikh Osama Bin Laden," saying that he left the world the way he wanted to.

Salafi jihadist Abu Qutaybah Majali recalled that Bin Laden was "anathema to the Americans and Jews and their allies."

Majali accompanied Bin Laden in Afghanistan from 1986 to 1991.

He vowed to "continue the jihad until the Day of Resurrection."

Salafists in Maan, an Islamist stronghold 250 km south of Amman, handed out sweets to celebrate his "martyrdom." That is usually done there where relatives of community members get killed in Iraq.

A town west of Amman had some shops close and raise black flags in a sign of mourning.

A spokesman for the Muslim Brotherhood in Jordan, Jamil Abu Bakr told Al Jazeera "Osama bin Laden, may God have mercy on him, chose this path knowing the cost of confrontation and resistance to America and its allies the dictators in the region."

He continued, "Although we disagree with bin Laden in his approach, he stuck to his principles until the last moment, and stood in the face of the most powerful global force for ten years and did not appear in any waiver of his beliefs."

"We believe that as long as there is injustice and aggression, there will be resistance with multiple approaches to this resistance."

Political analyst and expert on Islamic groups, Dr. Muhammad Abu Rumman, said Osama bin Laden is more popular in the Jordanian street than his second in command, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, who is from Jordan.

He told Al Jazeera that polls showed bin Laden's popularity even after the Amman bombings claimed by al-Zarqawi in 2005 and stated that this is because Bin laden didn't criticize Jordan and his focus was instead on Americans and Jews and the Western powers.

05/05 Links Pt2: “Mondoweiss” is a hate site; The Jihad on Free Speech Comes to Texas; Latma Ep11

From Ian:

“Mondoweiss” is a hate site
Mondweiss is basically one-stop shopping for anti-Israel news. Anything bad that goes on in Israel will be publicized and exaggerated at Mondoweiss. If you want to know the far-left anti-Israel party line on any recent event, Mondoweiss is the place to go.
So in a sense it’s understandable that people with an interest in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict read Mondoweiss, especially if they share the blog’s anti-Israel politics. I keep up sporadically with Mondoweiss largely because its posts sometimes find their way into my Facebook feed from some of my more left-wing friends.
I hope my Facebook friends and others recognize, however, that whatever Mondoweiss’ value as a news aggregator, it is also a hate site.
Mondoweiss tries to preserve a fine line between hostility to Jews and hostility to Israel, but every once in a while, Weiss reminds us that the blog’s entire existence owes to the fact that he can’t maintain that separation.
The most dramatic example I’ve seen arrived in my Facebook feed last week via a Jewish journalist who passed it along with the comment, “Who thinks like this?”
In the course of a typical (for Weiss) rambling, somewhat incoherent post, titled, “Forgving the Anti-Semites,” Weiss makes the following claims, all of which are either unrelated to Israel or are only tangentially related to Israel–unless you believe that whatever Israel’s sins, they are not the “normal” sins of a nation-state, but somehow inextricably tied to the shortcomings of Jews.
Bernard-Henri Lévy: In Praise of Blasphemy
American friends, especially PEN Club writers, please read, right now, Caroline Fourest's new book, Eloge du blasphème (In Praise of Blasphemy, Grasset 2015), if you wish to understand:
1. why Charlie Hebdo was and is more respectful to Muslims than the idiots who think they are honoring Islam by killing;
2. that the real provocateurs were not the cartoonists themselves but those who waved the cartoons under the noses of Muslims who otherwise would not have seen them, thereby stirring up demonstrations that served, here, to draw attention from their own infamy; there, to appropriate the mantle of true defender of the prophet; or, on other occasions, to apply pressure in one or another international negotiation (for example, on nuclear power);
3. that the cover Charlie Hebdo ran after the killing, the cover depicting the prophet with a tear in his eye and the caption "All is forgiven," was the most peaceful, elegant, and conciliatory message conceivable and that those who asserted otherwise were inflammatory cynics; (h/t Alexi)
Latma: We'll be the Judge, episode 11
The eleventh episode of the Israeli satire program "We'll be the Judge," from the creators of Latma's Tribal Update, Israel Channel 1, April 30, 2015.




So what does the Jewish Nakba mean to you?
Zochrot have produced a short video clip to promote their mission: “So wait a moment, what is the Nakba?” Unsuspecting Israelis strolling on the Tel Aviv tayelet are quizzed on what the Nakba means to them.
I don’t know what is more worrying. The appalling ignorance of the Israeli public in this video — or the fact that Zochrot are asking the question in the first place.
In an altercation on Facebook with Eitan Bronstein Aparicio, one of the Zochrot leaders, I pointed out that the Palestinian Arabs were victims of their own leadership. Had the Arabs won the 1948 war, members of Zochrot, along with all the Jews of Israel, would surely have ended up at the bottom of the Mediterranean sea. And what did Zochrot think about the Jewish Nakba, I asked — the 870,000 Jewish refugees driven and dispossessed from Arab countries? Why were Zochrot exercised by one injustice, but coolly indifferent to another?
Time to shame Europe
On April 25, a Haifa theater staged a play that could be construed as a show of solidarity with a terrorist who kidnapped and murdered Israeli soldier Moshe Tamam in 1984. One of the organizers of the play was the group Coalition of Women for Peace. This group supports boycotts against Israel and is funded by the European Union, Germany, Sweden and the Netherlands.
On Memorial Day for Fallen Soldiers and Victims of Terrorism last month, while Israelis attended ceremonies honoring Israel's fallen, the organizations Combatants for Peace (funded by Spain, Germany and the Netherlands) and the Parents Circle Families Forum (funded by the U.S., the European Union and Switzerland) held an "alternative" ceremony, to which families of terrorists were invited.
On Independence Day, the organization Zochrot (funded by Germany, Belgium, Finland, the U.K., Switzerland and the Netherlands), which seeks the dissolution of the State of Israel and the return of Palestinian refugees, was especially active.
Despite the understandable public protest over the activities of these groups, one of the cornerstones of an independent and sovereign nation is the right to debate, to argue and to influence. It is the only way for the people to decide their own future. And indeed, as heated as it may get, the democratic debate among the Israeli public is one of the state's greatest strengths. But the problem begins when outsiders, who represent foreign political interests, interfere in our inner dialogue in a way that is not at all proportional.
Attack on Jewish Bookstore in Barcelona Thwarted
Last month, Spanish police arrested 11 Islamist extremists who were operating at 17 locations across the country’s northeastern region of Catalonia. After a year-long investigation, police detained ten men and one woman, aged 17 to 45, who were all “assumed to be implicated in diverse crimes related to jihadist terrorism, especially linked to Islamic State,” Reuters reported. Today, The Wall Street Journal confirmed those suspicions by reporting that the extremists, called the Islamic Fraternity for the Preaching of Jihad, had planned to destroy a Jewish bookstore in Barcelona:
The cell, which featured prominent roles for converts to Islam, tried to recruit fighters to join Islamic State in Syria and developed plans to bomb a Jewish bookstore in Barcelona and snatch and behead a captive, according to police and prosecutors in court documents.
These arrests bring the total number of persons detained in Spain so far in 2015 for suspected ties to terrorism to 42, according to Spain’s Foreign Ministry. Last year, 46 such arrests were made.
Graphic Novel Legends Neil Gaiman, Art Spiegelman Step Up to Honor Charlie Hebdo at PEN Gala
Last week, six writers serving as table hosts for the PEN American Center gala withdrew to protest the Freedom of Expression Courage Award given to Charlie Hebdo magazine. Now six new writers, including graphic novel legends Neil Gaiman and Art Spiegelman, have stepped forward to take their places. Their gesture is more important and appreciated than ever, in light of the anti-free speech attack in Texas on Sunday night.
In addition to Gaiman and Spiegelman, the Associated Press reports Alison Bechdel, George Packer, Azar Mafisi, and Alain Mabanckou will be table hosts, replacing Michael Ondaatje, Francine Prose, Peter Carey, Rachel Kushner, Teju Cole, and Taiye Selasi. Their withdrawal came less than two weeks before the scheduled event, leaving little time for replacements to come forward.
The replacement hosts seem to understand that the governments of civilized nations have an even more potent moral obligation to protect their citizens from murder at the hands of fascist gunmen. “The Charlie Hebdo PEN award is for courage. The courage to work after the 2011 firebombing of the offices, the courage to put out their magazine in the face of murder,” Gaiman told the New York Times. “If we cannot applaud that, then we might as well go home… I’ll be proud to host a table on Tuesday night.”
Gaiman further told the AP he could not understand why “several otherwise well-meaning writers have failed to grasp that you do not have to like what is said to support people’s right to say it.”
PC Thought-Bots Embarrass Themselves With PEN Boycott
PEN, the organization of writers, decided to give a Toni and James C. Goodale Freedom of Expression Courage award to Charlie Hebdo—that is, to those of its staff who were not massacred by the Islamist Kouachi brothers on Jan. 7. So, of course hell broke loose.
In its own words, PEN wished to “honor Charlie Hebdo for their refusal to retreat when confronted with threats of violence … coupled with their magnanimity in the face of tragedy.” In a longer statement, the organization declared:
It is the role of the satirists in any free society to challenge the powerful and the sacred, pushing boundaries in ways that make expression freer and more robust for us all. In paying the ultimate price for the exercise of their freedom, and then soldiering on amid devastating loss, Charlie Hebdo deserves to be recognized for its dauntlessness in the face of one of the most noxious assaults on expression in recent memory.
On the face of it, the Goodale Award would seem the ideal honor for Charlie Hebdo.
Hasbara…Hasbara Everywhere
Last week Israel took criticism for sending a contingent of doctors and search and rescue specialists to Nepal to participate in the earthquake relief efforts. Read that again. There is no “not” in between “for” and “sending.” The Israel Defense Forces sent 260 doctors, nurses, and personnel trained in finding disaster victims to Katmandu after the major (7.8 on the Richter scale) earthquake…and it was quickly dismissed as propaganda to deflect attention from Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and the humanitarian conditions in the Gaza Strip. The Israelis have a lot to answer for when it comes to the Palestinians, from continued expropriation of Palestinian land in the West Bank to death and destruction in Gaza, but what do those issues have to do with earthquake relief in Nepal? Apparently everything the Israelis do is hasbara.
The criticism for the IDF’s Nepal mission from some well-known anti-Israel activists is to be expected even if it is bizarre, but for those genuinely interested in human rights it seemed rather odd to call the Israelis out for sending relief. Here I am thinking of a Tweet from Human Rights Watch’s Ken Roth: “Easier to address a far-away humanitarian disaster than the nearby one of Israel’s making in Gaza. End the blockade!” Never mind the fact that Roth seems to be implying that the Israelis are disqualified from sending relief to Nepal because of Gaza; he seems so blithely unaware of just how difficult it actually is to address the humanitarian situation in Gaza. Had I seen the Tweet in real-time, I would have responded with all seriousness, “Yes, it is much easier.” Let’s review why it is easier for the Israelis to provide relief in Nepal than in Gaza:
1)    Since 2005, about 15,000 rockets have been fired at Israel from the Gaza Strip, though not all of them landed in Israel.
2)    The Nepalese have not fired a single rocket at Israel.
3)    There is no solution to the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians.
4)    There is no conflict between Israelis and Nepalese.
The rabbi of Nepal
Unlike other NGOs around the world, Tevel b’Tzedek didn’t need to send a rescue team to Nepal following the devastating earthquake that has killed and wounded thousands. That’s because Tevel bTzedek was already there. For the last eight years, Tevel b’Tzedek (the name is taken from Psalms, and means “the world with justice”) has been connecting young Israelis with Nepal, one of the world’s poorest countries.
Tevel’s goal is to help Nepali villagers enter the modern world without losing their sense of community and traditions. The highest level of charity, according to Maimonides, is to help someone become self-sufficient, and that’s how Tevel works. Tevel’s local Nepali staff of nearly 50 people, headed by a Nepali with a PhD in agronomy from Ben-Gurion University, teach farmers how to create irrigation systems and market their produce, and empower women to become village leaders. Israeli and Jewish volunteers work together with the local staff. One Tevel volunteer, working with his Nepali counterpart, adopted the model of an Israeli youth movement and created a Nepali equivalent, with a thousand members.
“We want to help villagers feed themselves and more,” says Micha. “That way people won’t move to the Kathmandu slums, where they lose their sense of community and the little they have. And with much of the country now devastated by the earthquake, that’s even more important. If people leave the villages, then less food will be grown. Our work was already a matter of life and death for the villages; now that’s true for the rest of the country as well.”
Body of Israeli killed in Nepal quake to arrive in Israel
The body of 22-year-old Or Asraf was expected to arrive in Israel for burial on Tuesday, following a strenuous search and rescue effort in the Langtang Nature Park in Nepal led by his comrades from the elite Egoz reconnaissance unit.
Asraf was the last Israeli unaccounted for following the quake on April 25. His body was found on Sunday, eight days after the quake, and was later flown to Kathmandu in a helicopter provided by the Isralife Foundation, one of the groups assisting in Nepal. He was apparently killed in a massive rock slide.
Asraf's girlfriend, Amit Greenberg, shared on Facebook a text exchange they had before the earthquake struck. He sent her a photo in which he is pictured smiling on a snowy mountaintop.
"This is the best place for me," he wrote. "Up in the mountains?" Greenberg responded. "That too, in Nepal in general ... I'm in love with this country," he answered.
IDF Blog: The Last Journey: the Story of Or Assraf
Or Assraf z”l fought in Operation Protective Edge, was injured in battle, recovered and set out on a trip to the Far East. When a disastrous earthquake struck Nepal during his trip, Or’s family, friends and former comrades followed him across the world in an attempt to locate him and bring him home. Or was found, but tragically did not complete his journey. This is his brave, moving story.
Or was the son of Patrick and Orit and a brother to Ella. He lived with his family in Lehavim, Israel. His many friends described him as sweet, talented, big hearted, patriotic and compassionate. He drafted into the IDF in October 2011 as a soldier in the special unit “Shaldag”, and later in his service was transferred to the special unit “Egoz.”
During Operation Protective Edge Or participated in the difficult battle in the neighbourhood of Shu’jaya in Gaza. On July 21, 2014 he lost two of his comrades and friends- Tal Yefrach z”l and Yuval Dagan z”l. During the battle, Or was charged with clearing a house in which terrorists were hiding. He was moderately injured and was later hospitalized and treated. “I thought about the worst possible scenario. Death was something that went through my mind, moving a centimeter to the right or the left made all the difference between life and death. I know that I have to move on, and my heart is with the families of my friends who fell. One has to know how to lift one’s head and move on with one’s life. That’s what they [my friends] wanted us to do,” said Or two months after Operation Protective Edge.
Or’s Solitary and Brave Journey
After the operation, Or recovered from his injuries and was released from the army. He decided to realize his life-long dream, to travel, and he set out on a long trip that was due to end in July of 2015. While on his trip, Or kept in touch with the mothers of his friends who fell. He took pictures of himself holding his friends’ photo, so that their spirit could live on with him.
The last recording of him is a voice message he sent three days before the earthquake to Aviva Yefrach, Tal’s mother. In the recording he can be heard saying: “Hello Aviva. I’m here in Nepal, volunteering in an ecological village. Soon I will go to the local school to teach children English and then I will travel to Kathmandu, where Chabad is holding a memorial service in honor of IDF soldiers who fell in battle. I will tell them stories about Tal and Yuvi. Know that I love you. You are like a mother to me. I wish I could be there with you for Memorial Day, I really do miss you and when I get back I will be with you. Stay strong.”
CAMERA Prompts Corrections on Aid to Nepal
Based on an incomplete and misleading CNN graphic, several English-language Israeli and Jewish media outlets erroneously reported that the Israeli rescue mission to Nepal was the largest of any country's delegation in manpower. In fact, India's delegation was the largest. Following communication from CAMERA's Israel office, Times of Israel, The Algemeiner and i24news have commendably corrected their articles.
In an apparent oversight, the CNN graphic did not include the country which contributed the most manpower to the relief effort: India. According to the United Nations' Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, India's delegation was comprised of over 450 personnel. According to an April 27 article from the Himalayan News Service ("India sends largest rescue contingent"), " . . . India sent 348-member search and rescue team [sic], including three sniffer dogs to Nepal, the largest rescue team as far as foreign rescue team are concerned."
It is true, though, relative to the countries' respective populations, Israel's delegation of 260 is proportionally the largest (as well as second in absolute figures.)
Phyllis Chesler: The Jihad Against Free Speech Comes to Texas
We are living in infamous times. Reality outpaces fiction, and the worst case scenarios keep unfolding in our daily headlines.
Critics of torturers and mass murderers are demonized as "extremists" and "provocateurs." Israel is accused of human rights atrocities it has never committed by those very entities who themselves actually commit such atrocities; anyone who points this out is deemed an "extreme conservative" and a "racist." Anti-infidel hate speech—as long as it is directed against America and Israel—is seen as protected by the First Amendment and by the doctrine of Free Speech; exposing the diabolical Big Lies is considered politically incorrect "racist" hate speech which has no place in the Western media, on campus, at the UN, or in any international human rights organization.
Either the West fights back or it surrenders to these Orwellian rules. Many Western intellectuals prefer scapegoating Israel and surrendering quietly to these diabolical Islamist rules rather than risk their reputations and their lives.
Islamic State claims Texas attack, its first on US soil
The Islamic State jihadist group on Tuesday claimed responsibility for its first attack on US soil, a shooting at an event in Texas showcasing cartoons mocking the Prophet Mohammed that left the gunmen dead.
“Two of the soldiers of the caliphate executed an attack on an art exhibit in Garland, Texas, and this exhibit was portraying negative pictures of the Prophet Mohammed,” the jihadist group said.
“We tell America that what is coming will be even bigger and more bitter, and that you will see the soldiers of the Islamic State do terrible things,” the group announced.
CAIR Advised Muslims to ‘Use Caution’ Speaking to FBI About ‘Draw Muhammad’ Event Shooter in 2010
The Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR), an American Muslim advocacy group with deep ties to the global Muslim Brotherhood, advised Muslims to “use caution” when talking to the FBI about its 2010 investigation into Elton Simpson, who on Sunday carried out a jihadist attack on a “Draw Muhammad” free-speech event in Garland, Texas.
According to a 2010 article in the Arizona Muslim Voice, which describes Simpson as “humble, pious, [and] well liked in the community,” CAIR “sent out media alerts to advise our community to use caution when speaking with the FBI.” The author of the piece, Kawthar Ijai, said at the time that CAIR’s advice “is for our own protection.”
CAIR was listed as an unindicted co-conspirator in the largest terrorism financing trial in United States history. The American Muslim group was accused of raising money for the Holy Land Foundation, a charity that had solicited millions of dollars for Palestinian terrorist group Hamas. The United Arab Emirates recently listed CAIR independently as a terrorist organization.
2010 Arizona Muslim Publication: Texas Shooter 'Well-Liked,' 'Kids Adore Him'
Simpson and an accomplice, reportedly armed with AK-47 assault rifles, attempted to carry out an attack on a “Draw Muhammad” free-speech event hosted by Pamela Geller, president of the anti-jihad group American Freedom Defense Initiative (AFDI). Both jihadists were shot dead by police before they could inflict damage upon the event’s attendees.
In a 2010 profile of Simpson, after he had been arrested following an FBI terrorism investigation, author Kawthar Ijai wrote that he had adopted the Muslim name Ibrahim. Simpson was described as “the kind of person who always has a positive word for everyone and has a bright outlook, especially when you start talking about his favorite topic – Islam.”
“Kids adore him. He is always talking to the kids on their level, throwing a ball around with them and playing games with them,” said the author. “They actually come home from their classes with some knowledge about the character of the Prophet Muhammad,” she added.
Lauryn Hill cancels Israel show
US songstress Lauryn Hill announced Monday that she was canceling her scheduled performance in Israel on Thursday, citing a “challenge” in setting up a show in Ramallah for Palestinian fans as well.
Hill said that when she agreed to play in Israel, her intention was to set up a performance in the Palestinian territories “to be a presence supporting justice and peace.”
“It is very important to me that my presence or message not be misconstrued, or a source of alienation to either my Israeli or my Palestinian fans. For this reason, we have decided to cancel the upcoming performance in Israel, and seek a different strategy to bring my music to ALL of my fans in the region,” she wrote in a message on Facebook on Monday.
The R&B, soul and hip hop artist, whose 1998 album “The miseducation of Lauryn Hill” won five Grammy Awards including Album of the Year, did not mention what the difficulty in setting up a show in the West Bank stemmed from.
The misleading of Ms. Lauryn Hill
Sorry, Ms. Lauryn Hill but your statement doesn’t cut it. People are interpreting your cancellation as you boycotting the world’s only Jewish country.
Is that true? In which case – you need to own it.
Did you get bullied by the vicious rhetoric of the anti-Israel mob on social media? Say so.
Are we to understand that you will only play to one country or set of people if you can also simultaneously play to anyone they are in conflict with? Good luck finding a venue like that in this world!
In the end, your cancellation is being seen by those who are both racist and anti-peace as a victory. It’s being seen as a victory for those who would suppress your performance and see that in some way as good. Your cancellation demonizes one set of people and demoralizes those who really, truly want peace in the region. And whatever the case, don’t judge – see things for yourself.
California Community colleges reject BDS
The largest educational system in the United States -the California Community College System- has said no to BDS.
During their semi-annual meeting on May 3rd, the General Assembly of the Student Senate of California Community Colleges (GASSCCC) voted against divestment with a final vote of 25 in favor, 44 opposed, and six abstentions.
Over 2.1 million students are represented by the General Assembly of the Student Senate of California Community Colleges.
The California Community colleges join the University of Toledo, the University of Texas at Austin, University of Michigan, UC Santa Barbara, Princeton and the University of New Mexico- all of whom have defeated anti-Israel resolutions in the past few weeks.
Danish group vows to expand ads against Israeli settlements
A Danish group on Monday vowed to expand an advertising campaign urging people to boycott products from Israeli settlements after the ads were dropped from Copenhagen buses.
“It’s a clear attempt to deny us our freedom of speech,” Fathi El-Abed, chairman of the Danish Palestinian Friendship Association, told AFP after bus operator Movia last week pulled the campaign.
“There is nothing whatsoever about this campaign that is harmful, discriminatory or hateful in any way,” he added.
The advertisements on 35 buses in the Copenhagen area pictured two women beside the quote: “Our conscience is clean! We neither buy products from the Israeli settlements nor invest in the settlement industry.”
UCLA party that disputed Jewish candidate’s fitness loses election
Lets Act! (LA), the far-left student political party at UCLA, was dramatically swept from power, in election results released Friday, May 1, 2015.
LA, a coalition of mostly identity-based groups (e.g. Afrikan Student Union, MEChA, Queer Alliance, etc.) was defeated 8 seats to 3 (with 3 independents) by their rival, Bruins United (BU), a coalition of most everyone else (led by the Jewish community, fraternities, and sororities).
LA and its constituent groups constituted the bulk of left-wing identity politics efforts at UCLA.
LA was responsible for slew of anti-Israel actions: Two BDS resolutions at UCLA; objecting to the Judicial Board appointment to Rachel Beyda because she is Jewish; and attempts to disqualify candidates who took trips to Israel.
The election likely was influenced by the release by an anonymous Whistleblower of years of alleged internal documents posted online. As reported by The Daily Bruin, LA allegedly funded their campaigns by dealing drugs and misappropriating student government funds. (LA denies the charges.)
Daphne Anson: In Britain, Leftwing Hypocrites Betray Gender Equality In Pursuit Of Muslim Votes
At a secular political meeting in Birmingham addressed by Labour Party heavies including Jack Dromey, husband of ex-Cabinet Minister Harriet Harman who is an ultra-feminist if ever there was one, women are seated on the left of their menfolk, who by contrast are seated on the right, befitting their superior status.
Yes, this is an audience of Muslims, and, even though the occasion is a civic one, not a religious one, they've insisted on gender apartheid.
When such a thing happened some years ago at the insistence of a Muslim mayor in the East End of London, there was much indignation, and at least one Muslim councillor of the inferior sex was among those doing the grumbling.
Hey, but there's a General Election on, and the speakers from the Labour Party, Jack Dromey and the rest of the gang, show that when it comes to catching votes they're fully prepared to sell modern British values down the river.
South African Student President Axed: 'I Love Adolf Hitler'
Until Monday, Dlamini was president and a member of the Students' Representative Council of the University of the Witwatersrand in Johannesburg, South Africa. According to a release by the school's vice chancellor Adam Habib, Dlamini was asked to step down from his post immediately and his membership in the organization has been revoked. Habib insists that Dlamini's comments in no way influenced the university's decision, but did say they could not be ignored. "I have referred the matter to the Legal Office for investigation," Habib wrote. "This matter will take its due course."
Speaking to the university's paper Wits Vuvuzela prior to the school's announcement, Dlamini doubled down, saying, “What I love about Hitler is his charisma and his capabilities to organise people. We need more leaders of such cailbre. I love Adolf Hitler." [sic]
Dlamini also told WV that he wasn't using the social media platform to "nurse Jewish people's feelings" and said Facebook is "an academic space" where debates should take place. "Truth hurts… face it murderers," he wrote on his page.
When Dlamini was under review by the vice chancellor, he wrote a commentary for WV stating that the university is "an anti-black space" and one that "privileges white bodies." He accused Habib of failing to punish a white student who allegedly screamed to another student, "I will f***in' kill you, you black bitch!" He also leveled accusations that black workers at the university go unpaid and are banned from using some of the school's facilities.
Rasmea Odeh Prosecutor gets Arab-American Justice Award
We reported last week that supporters of convicted terrorist and immigration fraudster Rasmea Odeh were protesting a Justice Award to U.S. Attorney Barbara McQuade, Rasmea Odeh Prosecutor to get Justice Award.
The Justice Award was given by the Michigan-based Arab-American Civil Rights League (ACRL) among other groups, including the local NAACP chapter.
Rasmea’s supporters were furious, demanding that the Justice Award be revoked. They launched a social media campaign encouraging people to dall the ACRL, and issued veiled threats of retaliation.
Many of the tweets were what we have come to expect in the case, a complete distortion of the reality of Rasmea’s guilt:
Honest Reporting: Radio: The BBC’s Guerin Defense and Jimmy Carter’s Praise for Hamas
HonestReporting’s Yarden Frankl joins VOI’s Josh Hasten to discuss this week’s media coverage of Israel including the BBC’s response to complaints about Orla Guerin’s Gaza conflict dispatch and coverage of former U.S. President Jimmy Carter’s praise for Hamas.
Czech anti-Semitism spiked in 2014, report shows
The number of anti-Semitic incidents in the Czech Republic rose by more than 200 percent last year, according to an annual report on anti-Semitism.
Prague’s Jewish community released the report on Monday.
In 2014, 46 such incidents were registered across the country, compared to 13 incidents the previous year. An escalation of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, notably Israel’s military operation in Gaza last July and August, was seen as the main factor fueling the surge.
“It is clear that the Czech Republic’s Jewish community becomes a target of anti-Semitism in relation to the situation in the Middle East,” the chair of the Jewish community of Prague, Jan Munk, said in a statement.
“Czech Jews are perceived by some groups as envoys of the state of Israel and are blamed for its political decisions.”
Polish ex-minister who saved Jews during WWII buried
European Council president Donald Tusk and German President Joachim Gauck attended the state funeral ceremonies on Monday for Wladyslaw Bartoszewski, Poland’s former foreign minister and a former Auschwitz prisoner who helped save Jews from the Holocaust.
Bartoszewski, a historian, writer and politician, died suddenly on April 24 at the age of 93. He was Poland’s deputy minister for dialogue with Germany and Israel.
A member of underground World War II resistance, Bartoszewski helped save Jews and was honored by Israel with the title of the Righteous Among Nations. He was later persecuted under communism for his democratic views. He served twice as democratic Poland’s foreign minister.
Knesset Speaker Yuli Edelstein marked Bartoszewski’s death on Monday, calling it “a huge loss, not only to Poland and the State of Israel, but to humanity, which lost a moral voice that didn’t hesitate to speak out, even at a heavy personal cost.”
Abbott pays tribute to Jewish diggers
Prime Minister Tony Abbott has paid tribute to Australia's 'Jewish warrior citizens' at an Anzac commemoration service in Sydney.
More than one in 10 Australian Jews - some 2500 - volunteered for World War I a century ago, 300 of whom never returned.
'Jewish people made a more than proportionate contribution to the war effort,' Mr Abbott said at the service at The Great Synagogue in Sydney's CBD on Sunday.
He paid special tribute to General Sir John Monash, whose tactical nous helped break the trench warfare stalemate on the Western Front.
'His name should be as familiar in the future as it has been in the past,' Mr Abbott told the packed temple.
He also used the occasion to defend Australia's ongoing military presence in the Middle East.
'We seek no dominion, we seek no changes of borders or changes of faith,' he said.
'We simply work with all men and women of goodwill to preserve and advance the universal decencies of mankind.'
Israeli firm to bring election results direct to UK living rooms
The UK’s most exciting election in recent years deserves its most exciting election coverage ever, said John Ryley, director of Sky News. To ensure that its coverage is exciting, the broadcaster will be employing technology made by Israel’s LiveU, by now a veteran of many an election contest, as well as the go-to firm for broadcasters of top international sporting events, like the Olympics, the World Cup, and many more.
As the returns come in from all corners of the United Kingdom on May 7, Sky News will be posting staff at over 270 locations across England, Scotland, and Wales. Instead of dispatching 270 plus professional camera crews with terrestrial and satellite broadcast equipment – a very expensive proposition – Sky will use LiveU’s small form-factor solutions, which use cell networks to beam broadcast-quality images across the world.
10 must-have experiences in Israel
Israel may be no larger than New Jersey, but the staggering amount of places to see and experience can be quite overwhelming for first-time and even repeat visitors.
Israel has the most museums per capita in the world and some of the most significant archeological and heritage sites anywhere. Add to that Mediterranean beaches, world-class cuisine, colorful outdoor markets, child-friendly attractions, extreme sports and globally renowned nightlife, and the big question becomes: Where do we even begin?
ISRAEL21c recommends these experiences to put at the top of your to-do list in Israel. If you have additional can’t-miss suggestions, please share them in the comments section.
1. Walk the ramparts of the Old City of Jerusalem
Oldest complete copy of Ten Commandments goes on display in Israel
The world’s oldest complete copy of the Ten Commandments is going on rare display at Israel’s leading museum in an exhibit tracing civilization’s most pivotal moments.
The 2,000-year-old Dead Sea Scroll, from a collection of the world’s most ancient biblical manuscripts discovered near the Dead Sea east of Jerusalem, has never before been publicly displayed in Israel and has only been shown in brief exhibits abroad, said Pnina Shor of the Israel Antiquities Authority.
The manuscript is so brittle that it will only be on display at the Israel Museum in Jerusalem for two weeks before it is returned to a secure, pitch-black, climate-controlled storage facility at the museum.
It is one of 14 ancient objects displayed in “A Brief History of Humankind,” an exhibit of historical objects spanning hundreds of thousands of years.

Pew poll: Egyptians want to scrap Camp David, prefer sharia law

A new Pew Research poll of Egypt shows some worrying trends.

No dividend emerges for the United States from the political changes that have occurred in Egypt. Favorable ratings of the U.S. remain as low as they have been in recent years, and many Egyptians say they want a less close relationship with America. Israel fares even more poorly. By a 54%-to-36% margin, Egyptians want the peace treaty with that country annulled.

The military is now almost universally seen (88%) as having a good influence on the way things are going in Egypt. Fully 90% rate military chief Mohamed Tantawi favorably.

Egyptians are welcoming some forms of change more than others. While half say it is very important that religious parties be allowed to be part of the government, only 27% give a similar priority to assuring that the military falls under civilian control. Relatively few (39%) give high priority to women having the same rights as men. Women themselves are more likely to say it is very important that they are assured equal rights than are men (48% vs. 30%). Overall, just 36% think it is very important that Coptic Christians and other religious minorities are able to freely practice their religions.

Egyptians hold diverse views about religion. About six-in-ten (62%) think laws should strictly follow the teachings of the Quran. However, only 31% of Egyptian Muslims say they sympathize with Islamic fundamentalists, while nearly the same number (30%) say they sympathize with those who disagree with the fundamentalists, and 26% have mixed views on this question. Those who disagree with fundamentalists are almost evenly divided on whether the treaty with Israel should be annulled, while others favor ending the pact by a goodly margin.
If more than half of those who favor Shari'a law are not sympathetic to "fundamentalists," this means that the Arab definition of "fundamentalist" is much different than the Western definition. After all, wanting to have the nation ruled by religious law is, by definition, a fundamentalist position.

This means that Western journalists and pundits who try to paint the Muslim Brotherhood as outside the mainstream of Egypt are missing the real story.

Only 20% of Egyptians hold a favorable opinion of the United States, which is nearly identical to the 17% who rated it favorably in 2010. Better educated and younger Egyptians have a slightly more positive attitude toward the U.S. than do other Egyptians.

Looking to the future, few Egyptians (15%) want closer ties with the U.S., while 43% would prefer a more distant relationship, and 40% would like the relationship between the two countries to remain about as close as it has been in recent years.
So in what sense is Egypt considered an "ally" of the US again?

The worst way to form a government, except for all the others (Vic Rosenthal)


Vic Rosenthal's weekly column:


Earlier this week, Avigdor Lieberman decided, for some reason, that he would not join PM Netanyahu’s coalition (yes, he gave ‘reasons’, but nobody takes them seriously). Coalition negotiations with Naftali Bennett’s Jewish Home party, the last to get on board, continued until a few hours before the deadline for Netanyahu to present his putative coalition of 61 Knesset members to President Rivlin.

As I make the final update to my post on Thursday morning, the excitement is over. Bennett demanded and got the Justice Ministry portfolio for Ayelet Shaked. There will be a Likud government with 61 mandates, the narrowest possible margin, a government that can be knocked over by the defection of a single member.

There were other possibilities. Netanyahu and Bennett might not have come to agreement, or some other member of the coalition suddenly might have decided to make a new demand despite having signed an agreement. Netanyahu might have chosen to invite Labor’s Herzog into a unity government; given the proper inducements, he would have agreed despite his protestations.

If Netanyahu hadn’t succeeded at the last moment, the President might have given the job of forming the coalition to some other Knesset member, like Herzog, who would probably have had even more trouble than Netanyahu. He might have tried to force a unity government. There is even the possibility that no member of the Knesset could form a coalition, in which case there would have to be new elections.

This is tremendously frustrating. There are big problems — internal and external — that require attention, and the PM and various party leaders who are ministers have spent almost two months negotiating with each other, having meetings (open and secret), hatching plots (Lieberman), etc. This is after the excruciating election campaign that went on from December to March.

I admire PM Netanyahu for being able to carry on at least the most important affairs of state during this protracted period, but this system is dysfunctional. And a 61-member coalition means that it isn’t over — Netanyahu will have to try to broaden the coalition after its inauguration unless he wants even more instability.

The parliamentary system is a good one, because it makes the government highly responsive to the will of the electorate, as expressed by their representatives in the Knesset. An ineffective government can be removed at any time. If only the US had such a system, Obama would be long gone! But the coalition process is problematic.

One suggestion is to simply get rid of the process by appointing as Prime Minister the leader of the party with the greatest number of seats. But this could have unintended consequences, if there are more than two parties in the race. Suppose there were three parties, two on the Right and one on the Left. If the right-wing parties received 39 seats each, and the single left-wing party got 52, the latter would win by a large margin — but the clear preference of the electorate for a right-wing government would be thwarted.

Another possibility would be to elect the Knesset and then have the MKs choose a Prime Minister from among themselves, by majority vote. One problem with this is that it removes the direct connection between the voter and the PM that is important if the people are to have confidence in the PM. Worse, it would produce backroom wheeling-and-dealing similar to what goes on in coalition negotiations, except that there wouldn’t be explicit coalition agreements.

What about direct election of a Prime Minister? Israel tried American-style separate elections for the Knesset and the Prime Minister in 1996 and 1999. This proved unsatisfactory because the elected PM didn’t necessarily have the base needed in the Knesset to form a stable coalition. Other suggestions that detach the PM from the Knesset could bring about the kind of paralysis that has characterized the relationship between the US President and the Congress.

Yet another idea would be to raise the minimum percentage of votes needed to enter the Knesset from the present 3.5% (5 Knesset seats) to a much larger value and then require that each party designate another party that would get its votes if it did not reach the threshold. This would make it more likely that one of the larger parties would get a majority, and simplify coalition negotiations if not. But it would also reduce the representation of minority views in the Knesset, in effect disenfranchising their voters (it could also produce an outcome with two large Jewish parties, each without a majority, and one smaller Arab party holding the balance of power).

Despite the frustration, this isn’t a simple problem, especially since the political propensity is to find ways to exploit unplanned loopholes in any system. Possibly, to paraphrase Churchill’s famous comment on democracy, the coalition system is the worst way to form a government — except for all the others.